5 Red Flags That a Client Isn't the Right Fit for Your CPA Firm
Apr 15, 2025
Not every client is a good client.
It's tempting to say yes to everyone - every business owner, every nonprofit, every individual who needed tax or accounting help. But the wrong clients create more stress, scope creep, and more headaches than they're worth.
Over time, I've developed a system for identifying red flags early so I could focus on working with clients who respect my time, value my expertise, and align with my firm's goals.
If you want to avoid burnout, late payments, and endless frustration, here are five red flags that a client isn't the right fit for your CPA firm - and how to handle them.
#1 They Push Back on Pricing or Ask for Discounts
The first sign that a client isn’t a good fit? They question your pricing from the start.
β “Can you do this cheaper?”
β “My last CPA charged less.”
β “Can I pay you after the work is done?”
π‘ Why It’s a Red Flag: Clients who haggle over fees don’t value your expertise. They see accounting services as a commodity rather than an investment. And if they’re trying to negotiate lower fees now, they’ll likely push back on invoices, delay payments, or expect free extras later.
β How to Handle It:
-
Be firm on your pricing and don’t negotiate. If they don’t see the value, they’re not the right client.
-
Offer clear pricing upfront so there’s no room for surprises.
-
If a client is already delaying payment before the engagement even starts, that’s a huge red flag—walk away.
#2 They Ignore Deadlines and Are Disorganized
Some clients are always scrambling at the last minute—missing deadlines, forgetting to send documents, and causing chaos for your firm.
π‘ Why It’s a Red Flag: Disorganized clients waste your time and increase stress, especially during busy season. When they don’t provide the necessary information, it delays your work and throws off your schedule.
β How to Handle It:
-
Set firm deadlines and require documents by a specific date—no exceptions.
-
Use automated reminders to nudge them to send missing items.
-
If they repeatedly miss deadlines and expect you to “fix it,” consider dropping them.
#3 They Expect Unlimited Access to You
Clients should respect your time and boundaries. But some clients text, email, and call at all hours—expecting instant responses and urgent solutions to non-urgent issues.
β “Hey, I know it’s 9 PM on a Saturday, but can you answer this quick tax question?”
β “I sent you an email two hours ago—why haven’t you responded?”
π‘ Why It’s a Red Flag: Clients who expect immediate, 24/7 access will quickly burn you out. If they don’t respect your boundaries now, it will only get worse over time.
β How to Handle It:
-
Set clear communication policies—let clients know your response time (e.g., 24-48 hours).
-
Use auto-responders to reinforce office hours.
-
If a client repeatedly ignores your boundaries, they’re not the right fit.
#4 They Don't Respect Professionalism or Ethics
If a client asks you to bend the rules, manipulate numbers, or overlook unethical behavior, that’s an immediate red flag.
β “Can we just write this off? No one will check.”
β “I don’t have documentation for that, but let’s just estimate.”
β “Can you change these numbers so my financials look better?”
π‘ Why It’s a Red Flag: As CPAs, our license and reputation are on the line. Working with unethical clients isn’t worth the risk.
β How to Handle It:
-
Be upfront—if they ask you to do something unethical, refuse immediately.
-
If they insist on shady practices, fire them as a client—your integrity is more important than their business.
π Non-Negotiable for Me: If a client asks me to fudge numbers or cut ethical corners, I immediately disengage. No second chances.
#5 They Drain Your Time and Energy (Without Paying For It)
Some clients are emotionally exhausting—constantly needing reassurance, asking for endless revisions, or overcomplicating simple processes.
β “Can we go over this again? I just want to be extra sure.”
β “I know we already finished my return, but I have a few more changes.”
β “I have just one more question…” (but it’s never just one more).
π‘ Why It’s a Red Flag: Clients who require excessive hand-holding drain your time and energy, preventing you from focusing on better, more profitable clients.
β How to Handle It:
-
Set clear boundaries on how many revisions or meetings are included in your service.
-
Implement value-based pricing—if they need extra work, they pay for it.
-
Politely but firmly redirect them—“I’d love to continue helping, and we can schedule an advisory session for an additional fee.”
Avoid Red Flags That a Client Isn't Right for Your CPA Firm
The wrong clients can drain your time, cause unnecessary stress, and impact your firm’s profitability. By identifying these red flags early, you can build a CPA firm that works with the right clients—ones who respect your expertise, pay on time, and align with your values.
π Key Takeaways:
β Pushing back on pricing is a sign they don’t value your expertise.
β Disorganized clients will create last-minute stress and delays.
β Clients who expect 24/7 access will never respect your time.
β Unethical clients put your reputation at risk—walk away.
β Clients who drain your energy aren’t worth it—set boundaries or charge more.
By screening clients carefully, you’ll create a firm that attracts and retains ideal clients—while avoiding the ones who make your job miserable.
Are you ready to set better boundaries and work only with the right clients?
Your Next Step Forward
JoinΒ the newsletter designed to help CPAs take the next best step in building a practice they love, with practical insights, game-changing tools, and quick wins in every email.
We hate SPAM. We will never sell your information, for any reason.
